16,000+ results
- Vtg 1998 Lisa Frank 24" Plush Rainbow Chaser Brown Pony Horse Stuffins StuffedOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$39.99Buy It Now+$14.40 delivery10 watchers
- Squishmallows 11" Grady the Gray Appaloosa Painted Horse Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$5.00or Best Offer+$5.91 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony Derpy Hooves Plush Plushie Figure 2025 Official 12" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$31.69Buy It Now+$12.99 deliveryAlmost gone
- Hasbro My Little Pony Princess Luna Plush Plushie Figure 2024 Official 15" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$45.00Buy It Now+$19.99 deliveryAlmost gone
- Hasbro My Little Pony Derpy Hooves Plush Plushie Figure 2024 Official 12" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$31.49Buy It Now+$14.19 deliveryLast one
- Douglas SOFT BROWN SPOTTED APPALOOSA PONY HORSE 20" Plush STUFFED ANIMAL ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$24.99or Best Offer+$10.95 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cuddle Rarity Plushie 2024 Official 15" L MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$149.99Buy It Now+$19.99 deliveryFree returnsLast one
Picked For You
Top selling items from trusted sellers | Sponsored- Vintage Hasbro Pony Surprise 1992 Mom With 3 Babies Plush Black & WhiteOpens in a new window or tab$71.50tresha1 (1,844) 99.3%17 watchers
- BOHO HORSESHOE SAK w/ HORSE Plush Stuffed Animal - Douglas Cuddle Toys - #2126Opens in a new window or tab$21.95douglas_cuddle_toys (9,647) 99.9%
- HEMIE the Plush Soft SPOTTED HORSE Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #4805Opens in a new window or tab$21.95douglas_cuddle_toys (9,647) 99.9%77 watchers
- Vintage Commonwealth Pinto Horse Plush 2001 Target Cuddle Zone 12" Brown WhiteOpens in a new window or tab$199.99samisbargains88 (1,353) 99.3%
- Warmies Microwavable Lavender Scented Plush Jr Horse Pony Brown Tan 9 inchOpens in a new window or tab$22.95sunderhomestead (2,714) 100%
- Disney Toy Story Bullseye 21" Plush NWT - USA SellerOpens in a new window or tab$23.99toyu-usa (3,584) 99.2%
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cuddle Sitting Rainbow Dash Plush Plushie Official 15" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$179.99Buy It Now+$19.99 deliveryLast one
- Hasbro My Little Pony Derpy Hooves Plush Plushie Figure 2024 Official 12" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$33.29Buy It Now+$12.49 deliveryLast one
- Pillowfort Weighted Plush Kids Throw Pillow Horse Design Brown DIRTY NOSEOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.99Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cuddle Lyra Plushie 2024 Official 15" L MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$79.99Buy It Now+$9.99 deliveryFree returnsAlmost gone
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cuddle Trixie Plush Plushie 2024 Official 15" L MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$99.99Buy It Now+$19.99 deliveryFree returnsLast one
- Dreamworks Spirit Riding Free 7" Set of 2 Horses Plush Stuffed Animals Toy RainOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.70Was: $24.955% offBuy It Now+$6.20 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony Princess Celestia Plush Plushie Figure 2024 Official MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$61.49Buy It Now+$19.99 delivery52 watchers
- Douglas Zoe Bay Horse Plush Brown Black Farm Stuffed Animal Toy #341Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$39.99or Best Offer+$10.99 delivery in 2-4 days10 watchers
- 2003 Commonwealth Black Horse Pellet Plush Stuffed AnimalOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$24.99or Best Offer+$16.65 delivery
- Huge Lot Of Girl Scouts Little Brownie Bakers Cookie Selling Prizes / IncentivesOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$79.99Was: $99.9920% offBuy It Now+$20.00 delivery
- My Little Pony Evergreen - HQG1C Custom G1 Exclusive Big BrotherOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$39.99Buy It Now+$6.50 delivery12 watchers
- My Little Pony Star Storm - HQG1C Custom G1 Friends Forever Convention ExclusiveOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$89.99Buy It Now+$6.75 delivery13 watchers
From our popular brands
Based on number of views and purchases | Sponsored- DouglasDouglas Cuddle Toys Black Horse White Blaze Face 11"Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$21.99+$6.40 delivery
- AuroraAurora Horse Large Plush 28" Big Brown Stuffed Animal RAREOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$38.00+$46.40 delivery
- DouglasDouglas Zoe Bay Horse Plush Brown Black Farm Stuffed Animal Toy #341Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$39.99+$10.99 delivery
- HandmadeHandmade Mexican Folk Art Floral Unicorn/Horse Stuffed Plush HandstitchedOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$29.99+$5.99 delivery
- IKEAIKEA White Horse Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Sewn Eyes CLEAN 17596 QOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$10.46+$4.99 delivery
- KellytoyKellytoy Plush Horse 11” Brown White Farm Stuffed Animal ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$9.00+$6.55 delivery
- CommonwealthVintage Commonwealth Pinto Horse Plush 2001 Target Cuddle Zone 12" Brown WhiteOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$199.99Free delivery
- AuroraAurora Fluffy Long Tail Blue Prancee Laying Horse Stuffed plushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$23.50+$6.55 delivery
- Hasbro 2024 My Little Pony DJ Pon-3 12" Plush Plushie Figure Exclusive MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$34.99Buy It Now+$9.00 delivery in 2-4 days
- NIB NEW LeMieux Hobby Horse Headcollar Toy Pony Kids Glacier Halter Lead RopeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$34.99or Best Offer+$4.84 delivery
- Squishmallow 12" Maverick Black Horse Midnight Cedar Point Exclusive OGOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$44.99or Best Offer+$8.99 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- NWT-Rallymen 2014 Plush Toy-Khartoum Severed Horse Head-from The Godfather MovieOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$55.21Was: $64.9515% offor Best Offer+$6.62 delivery
- Pokémon Center Spectrier and Glastrier Plush Toys NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$38.00Buy It Now+$6.66 delivery in 2-4 days
- Pillowfort Weighted Plush Kids Throw Pillow Horse Design Brown DIRTY NOSEOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$29.99or Best OfferFree delivery
- Stick Horse | Plush Handcrafted Hobby Horse | Stick Pony Provides Fun Pretend...Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$56.87Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cutie Apple Bloom Scootaloo Belle Plush Plushie Figure MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$55.90Buy It Now+$19.99 delivery53 watchers
- Thoroughbred Collection Fluffy BIG Plush Toy (Karen Chan)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$86.54Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom JapanFree returns
- Stick Horse | Plush Handcrafted Hobby Horse | Stick Pony Provides Fun Pretend...Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$56.87Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns
- Pony Surprise Jazzy Purple Pony & 2 Babies Plush Horse Ponies Just PlayOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$14.83or Best Offer+$10.50 delivery
- Vintage Chosun International Horse Plush Stuffed Animal Brown Black 24 Inch LongOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$59.00Buy It Now+$8.98 delivery
- Hallmark Rainbow Brite Sunriser Horse Plush KID3471 ~ NWT 🌈Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$31.44Was: $36.9915% offor Best Offer+$5.80 delivery
- WELLS FARGO MIKE 2016 Plush Pony Horse Brown Stuffed Animal NWT LegendaryOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$13.00or Best Offer+$10.00 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony MLP G4 'Derpy Hooves/Muffins' 10" Stuffed Animal PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$39.99or Best Offer+$8.85 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Jellycat Bashful Blossom Pony Horse Dahlia Light Blue Floral Feet RARE 12”Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$44.99or Best Offer+$8.85 delivery
- DOUGLAS CUDDLE Grace White Horse 20" Plush Reins Sparkle Stuffed AnimalOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$20.00Buy It Now+$19.28 delivery
- Vintage 2003 Rainbow Brite And Starlite Horse Hallmark Toy Doll Playset NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$32.99or Best Offer+$6.99 delivery
- Wells Fargo "Mack" Plush Horse Toy Brown Medium 14-24 in 2012Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$9.00Was: $12.0025% offBuy It Now+$6.84 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- 2018 DreamWorks Spirit Riding Free Pillow Buddy 18" Plush Horse Pony Stuffed ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$6.22Was: $8.3025% offor Best Offer+$8.71 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Spirit Stallion of the Cimarron Collection 18" Plush Horse Dreamworks VTG 2002Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$80.00or Best Offer+$7.16 delivery
- Nici Plush White Gray Horse Germany EUCOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$49.00Buy It NowFree delivery
- AMTOY Pink Wind Up Musical Pony Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 10” Vintage 1984Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$14.99or Best Offer+$9.10 delivery
- Warmies Microwavable Lavender Scented Plush Jr Horse Pony Brown Tan 9 inchOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$22.95or Best OfferFree delivery
- Kids Preferred Black Beauty Horse Pony White Star Plush Floppy Stuffed 22 InchOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$33.00or Best Offer+$9.99 delivery
- Oly Factory My Little Pony Princess Cadance 12" Stuffed Plush MLP 2021Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$74.99or Best OfferFree deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Dustie 10" Horse Mini Soft Plush Stuffed Animal Douglas Dappled Brown Cream PonyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$16.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returnsLast oneTop Rated Plus
- Stick Horse | Plush Handcrafted Hobby Horse Provides Fun Pretend Play for Tod...Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$56.87Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns
- My Little Pony Hasbro Cuddle Twilight Sparkle Plush Plushie Official 2024 MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$129.95or Best Offer+$9.95 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony Spike the Dragon Plush Plushie Figure 2025 Official MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$21.00Buy It Now+$19.99 deliveryLast one
- Douglas The Cuddle Horse #329 Maple Chestnut Horse Plush LargeOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$22.00or Best Offer+$6.84 deliveryFree returns10 watchers
- My Little Pony Maud Pie Plush USED As-Is READ PLEASEOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$149.99Buy It Now+$29.99 delivery in 2-4 days
- Barbie Magic Pegasus BRIETTA 18" Purple Plush Iridescent Wings Mattel Horse 2005Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$75.84Buy It NowFree delivery17 watchers
- 2016 Breyer Tan White Plush Stuffed Butterscotch Pinto Cartwright 20" Horse PonyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$24.95Buy It Now+$9.95 delivery19 watchers
- My Little Pony G3 Soft Plush Lot Cotton Candy Rainbow Dash Tink-a-Tink-a-Too NIBOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$42.99or Best OfferFree delivery52 watchers
- IT06394 Lemieux Tiny Pony - Sam NEWOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$28.45or Best OfferFree delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony Trixie Lulamoon Plush 2024 Official 10x15 Brand New.Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$74.99Buy It Now+$9.00 delivery in 2-4 days
- Aurora A&A Brown White Horse Pony Stuffed Animal Plush Backpack Bag 16”Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$49.99or Best Offer+$14.40 delivery
- HEMIE the Plush Soft SPOTTED HORSE Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #4805Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$21.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns77 watchers
- Disney Toy Story Bullseye 21" Plush NWT - USA SellerOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.99Buy It NowFree delivery
- Galloping Horse Plush Works As It ShouldOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.000 bids · Time left39mor Best Offer+$21.58 delivery
- Disney Pixar Signature Collection Toy Story Bullseye w/Sounds 16" Plush.Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$0.990 bids · Time left6d 15hor Best Offer+$9.95 delivery
- Realistic Laying Horse Brown White Stuffed Animal Plush Cuddly 17"Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$15.90or Best Offer+$8.50 delivery
- Douglas Duke Appaloosa Horse Stuffed Animal Pony White & Brown Plush Cuddle ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$22.99or Best Offer+$6.84 delivery
- Ganz Webkins Plush Clydesdale Horse HM139 Brown Stuffed Animal Toy Plush w TagsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$22.99Buy It Now+$6.55 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony 2013 Yellow Fluttershy 7 Inch Plush Pre-ownedOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$8.00or Best Offer+$4.84 deliveryFree returns
- My Little pony plush and plastic play horse toy mixed lot set of 4Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$15.00or Best Offer+$6.84 delivery
- Giant Pinky Pie My Little Pony 30-inch Tall Rare Authentic PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$90.00Buy It Now+$28.65 delivery
- Items Per Page
