81,000+ results
- (Blue Bare) Gabby's Dollhouse, 8-inch Cat Rat Cat rat Purr-ific Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$16.99Buy It NowFree delivery59 sold
- 2014 THE GODFATHER HORSE SEVERED HEAD 10" PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL RARE NEW WITH TAGOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$129.00Buy It NowFree delivery
- Large 36 Inch Tall Stuff Multicolor Gold Animal Lion Hug Fun Plush Toy & DecorOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$89.90or Best OfferFree deliveryFree returnsSave up to 20% when you buy more
- Jelly Cat Amusables Sports Swimming Goggles NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$39.98or Best OfferFree deliveryfrom China5 watchers
- Dodgers Hello Kitty Squishmallow Squish Plush SGA April 2025 MIP in packageOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$50.00Buy It Now+$7.00 delivery
- Sanrio Smiles 2000 Forest Fairy Hello Kitty w/Tiny Bear 8" Plush.Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$99.99Buy It Now+$4.52 delivery in 2-4 days
- [RARE] HELLO KITTY 2022 Valentine's Greeter 20 inches tallOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$50.00or Best OfferFree delivery
- Dreamy Rainbow Kitty Plush with Star Bow (12”)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.50or Best Offer+$4.33 delivery
Picked For You
Top selling items from trusted sellers | Sponsored- 2014 THE GODFATHER HORSE SEVERED HEAD 10" PLUSH STUFFED ANIMAL RARE NEW WITH TAGOpens in a new window or tab$129.00shoprobinson (4,519) 99.2%
- Creep Cat Toy Company 6 ft Striped Hyena Plush RARE! UN STUFFED RetiredOpens in a new window or tab$349.00countylineresale (7,553) 99.8%Save up to 5% when you buy more
- Save Our Space 8" Plush Snow LeopardOpens in a new window or tab$15.00baxters_bounty (5,784) 99.1%
- Vintage 1984 Arlene Plush Dakin Garfield Girlfriend Stuffed Animal Ships FreeOpens in a new window or tab$19.79theoldpaths (3,518) 100%
- DUKE the Plush APPALOOSA HORSE Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #2077Opens in a new window or tab$24.45douglas_cuddle_toys (9,763) 99.8%23 watchers
- HEMIE the Plush Soft SPOTTED HORSE Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #4805Opens in a new window or tab$23.45douglas_cuddle_toys (9,763) 99.8%Almost gone
- Disney Junior Minnies Pet Cat Figaro 8 Inch NWT USA SELLEROpens in a new window or tab$16.99toyu-usa (3,676) 99.1%252 sold
- Huge Plush Lot 19 Stuffed Animals! Taz, Lego, Disney, Care Bears, VTG, Cartoons!Opens in a new window or tab$55.55polo_plushy (1,755) 100%
- NEW Plushie Dreadfuls Victorian Cheshire Cat with Matching Tote (American McGee)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$50.00or Best Offer+$6.45 delivery
- Sanrio Hello Kitty Corduroy Plush – Pink Overalls (12”)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$25.00or Best Offer+$4.33 delivery
- Vintage Douglas Topaz CALICO CAT VHTFOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$350.00or Best Offer+$4.41 delivery in 2-4 days
- Creep Cat Toy Company 6 ft Striped Hyena Plush RARE! UN STUFFED RetiredOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$349.00Buy It NowFree deliverySave up to 5% when you buy more
- Twisted Whiskers Plush Cat 7” Brown Green Eyes American Greetings Stuffed ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$11.99or Best Offer+$6.55 delivery
- Hello Kitty as Tyler The Creator Plush Doll Rapper Figure Gift Collectable ViralOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$30.00Buy It NowFree delivery56 watchers
- Blue Bare Gabby's Dollhouse Baby Box Cat 8'' PlushOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$13.99Buy It NowFree deliverySave up to 12% when you buy more
- (Blue Bare) Gabby's Dollhouse, 10-inch CAT PLUSH TOY with Pink Shoulder BagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.99or Best OfferFree deliverySave up to 15% when you buy more
- Stuffies Plush toy Dash the Horse with Book F2Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$48.00or Best Offer+$16.55 delivery
- Dr Seuss Thing 1 Thing 2 Cat In Hat Movie Plush Stuffed 11” Vintage 2003Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$15.99Buy It Now+$7.35 delivery
- Gabby’s Dollhouse 10" Plush Pillow Cat Purr-ificOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.99or Best OfferFree deliverySave up to 7% when you buy more
- Squishmallows And Hello Kitty Cat Watermelon Slice Soft Plush Lot - 4 PlushiesOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$29.99or Best OfferFree delivery
From our popular brands
Based on number of views and purchases | Sponsored- KellytoyPre-Owned$10.50+$6.00 deliveryExtra 50% off with coupon
- DouglasBrand New$24.45Free delivery
- FiestaBrand New$55.00+$5.99 deliveryExtra 22% off with coupon
- DouglasBrand New$23.45Free delivery
- FiestaBrand New$34.95Free delivery
- AuroraBrand New$28.95+$9.67 delivery
- CommonwealthPre-Owned$28.00+$8.19 delivery
- Cats Vs Pickles Plush Hugger Water Meow 20” Soft Stuffed ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$32.50or Best Offer+$8.84 delivery
- 2001 Hasbro Playskool Bob the Builder Pilchard Blue Cat 8" PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$19.95or Best Offer+$9.00 delivery
- RARE & SEALED Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Blue Bow 2001Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$125.00or Best Offer+$11.38 delivery
- Dr Seuss Thing 1 Thing 2 Cat In Hat Movie Plush Stuffed 11” Vintage 2003Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$16.99Buy It Now+$7.35 delivery
- SOS SAVE OUR SPACE BLACK PANTHER BIG CAT STUFFED ANIMAL PLUSH TOY 12" 2016 NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$39.950 bids · Time left6d 22h+$7.95 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Cuddle Crew Stuffed Animal Plush -Cat With Donut NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.99or Best Offer+$6.50 delivery
- Phlox The Cat The Mysterious Doctor Plague Squishable PurpleOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$17.30or Best Offer+$7.50 deliveryFree returns
- NWT Cute Gund Pusheen Cat Narwhale Unicorn Blue 12” Plush Stuffed Animal ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.00or Best Offer+$4.71 delivery
- Bartholomew Bear Bathrobe Kids Girls Valentine's Gifts Jelly Cat Plush Cute ToysOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$27.59Was: $29.998% offor Best Offer+$8.00 deliveryfrom China10 watchers
- Perfect Petzzz Pets Calico Cat Sleeping Breathing Realistic Cat Toy Plush KittyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$24.95Buy It Now+$19.60 delivery
- Hello Kitty Valentine’s Day Greeter Side Stepper Animated Plush Gemmy Rare HtfOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$42.00or Best Offer+$16.65 delivery
- HUGIMALS Frankie The Cat 4.5lbs Large Weighted Stuffed Animal Plush for AnxietyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$13.50or Best Offer+$8.55 delivery
- Aphmau MeeMeows ~ Litter 4 Mystery Cat Plush - Sealed - Brand NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$9.06Was: $13.9435% offor Best Offer+$5.85 delivery8 watchers
- Cheetah Leopard Cat Classic Toy Character Rare hanging Jungle Plush JumboOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$54.99or Best Offer+$5.99 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Jazwares Pokémon Soft Plush 8" Sprigatito New with TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.99Buy It NowFree delivery in 2-4 daysLast one
- Super Mario Bros Luigi Cat Suit 24” Plush Toy – Nintendo NWT 2022 – Giant SoftOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$25.00or Best Offer+$10.00 delivery
- Squishmallows 8" Cameron The Cat Stuffed Animal Plush NWT - USA SELLEROpens in a new window or tabBrand New$18.99Buy It NowFree delivery61 sold
- Hasbro My Little Pony Cutie Apple Bloom Scootaloo Belle Plush Plushie Figure MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$43.90Buy It Now+$23.60 deliveryLast one
- Baby Three "Cat Wardrobe" Series: Rose Gold NEW Dora Eyes Open Bag, Card(No Box)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$25.99or Best Offer+$5.62 delivery
- NEW Coraline Cat Plush Anime Doll Cartoon Toy Fluffy Stuffed Dolls ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$36.71Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom PakistanLast one
- Squishmallows 2025 Valentine Squad A 5" Cicely the Cat Pizza Plush Doll ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.99or Best OfferFree delivery62 watchers
- JELLYCAT KITTEN CABOODLE CREAM WHITE CAT 4'' PLUSH TOY STUFFED ANIMAL RETIREDOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$29.99Buy It Now+$12.99 deliveryfrom Canada
- Vintage Hasbro Pony Surprise Mom Plush With 3 Mini Babies 1992 Black White HorseOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$26.99Buy It Now+$10.31 delivery
- Vintage HOOPS and YOYO New Old Stock Unused Hallmark Greeting Card & EnvelopeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.50Buy It Now+$2.00 delivery10 watchers
- Vintage Dakin Garfield Cat Plush Sitting Stuffed Animal 9" Toy Figure 1981 KoreaOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$38.00Buy It Now+$9.31 delivery
- HEMIE the Plush Soft SPOTTED HORSE Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys #4805Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.45Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returnsAlmost gone
- Coraline and Cat 8 Inch Phunny Plush KidrobotOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$12.00or Best Offer+$4.84 delivery
- Aphmau MeeMeows APHMAU Cat 6" Plush Glitter Edition Series 6Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.50Buy It NowFree deliveryLast one
- Sanrio Hello Kitty Flower Headband 8 Inch Plush Fiesta Stuffed Animal 2023Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$12.95or Best Offer+$4.84 delivery
- DASVIDANIYA THE TIE-DYE TABBY CAT Squishmallow 5x5x3" Plushy 2024 NEW w/TagsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.00or Best OfferFree delivery
- Rare Cat Face Plush Children Doll Soft PillowOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$39.99or Best Offer+$6.53 delivery in 2-4 daysFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Sanrio Hello Kitty Plush Patriotic 8" Stuffed Animal Toy July 4th USAOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.99or Best Offer+$5.99 deliveryFree returnsSave up to 15% when you buy moreTop Rated Plus
- Pusheen Ghost, Skeleton, Bat, Jack-o-Latern Halloween Plush Set of 4Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$78.37Was: $104.4925% offor Best OfferFree deliveryFree returnsLast one
- Warrior Cats Plush Ivypool Collectible Plush (new with tags)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$99.99or Best Offer+$12.99 deliveryLast one
- Pana The Black Panther | 42 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush | By TigerHart ToysOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$69.99Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns110 soldTop Rated Plus
- Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Olma Strawberry Cat - Official Jazwares PlushOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$17.38or Best OfferFree deliveryFree returnsSave up to 5% when you buy more
- Mario Kart -Cat Luigi 10" Plush - Nintendo 1372 New w/tagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$18.99Buy It Now+$6.75 delivery in 2-4 days
- Sigikid Beasts Town KIEZ MIEZ Cat Stuffed Animal Toy~Designer Plush GermanyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$65.00or Best OfferFree deliveryFree returns
- EARL THE DEAD CAT Plush Toy Reissue NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$24.99Buy It Now+$9.45 delivery159 sold
- Plush Sminky Pinky Kitty Cat Beasts Town HTF 14”Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$89.00or Best Offer+$8.85 delivery
- Lot 5 Sanrio Hello Kitty & Friends Tee Turtle Gudetama My Melody Sherbet KittyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$42.99Buy It Now+$8.99 delivery
- Vintage Fordlet Kitty Cat Tan Plush 12" Stuffed Animal Brown Heart Bow 1989Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$29.99Buy It Now+$6.99 delivery
- Hasbro My Little Pony Derpy Hooves Plush Plushie Figure 2024 Official 12" MLPOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$189.99Buy It Now+$24.00 deliveryLast one
- Warrior Cats Mini Plush Toy 6" Brightheart ThunderClan CatOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$28.62Was: $31.8010% offBuy It Now+$5.00 deliveryfrom China17 watchers
- 8" CATNAP POPPY PLAYTIME SMILING CRITTERS OFFICIAL PLUSH LICENSED IN HANDOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.99Buy It NowFree delivery132 sold
- (Blue Bare) Gabby's Dollhouse, 8-inch Cat Rat Cat rat Purr-ific Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.99or Best OfferFree delivery
- Aphmau Meow-Meows Hamburger Cat Jumbo 24" Plush MeeMeows CatFaceOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$59.95Buy It Now+$28.68 delivery
- Knitted stuffed plushy yarn lion animal toy 14"X12"X4"Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.00or Best OfferFree delivery
- Build A Bear Gray Snow Leopard Cat 16" Plush w/ Leopard Print Shirt Black ShortsOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$19.950 bids · Time left9d 22h+$16.65 delivery
- Aphmau MeeMeows Carnival Treats S’mores Cat Plush 11” New Opened PackagingOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$34.99or Best Offer+$6.07 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Adopt Me! Plush 8" Pet SNOW CAT with Exclusive Virtual Code NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.00or Best Offer+$4.71 delivery
- Vintage Felt Stuffed Toy Large Cat Embroidered Body Stripes & Face Display PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$14.990 bids · Time left6d 22hor Best Offer+$9.45 delivery
- Lot Of 2 Sanrio Hello Kitty Cinamaroll Sailor 8” SquishmallowsOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$22.99Buy It Now+$6.99 delivery
- Squishmallows Hello Kitty and Friends 7" Sailor Blue Hello Kitty - Kellytoy 2022Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$10.50Buy It Now+$6.00 deliveryFree returnsExtra 50% off with coupon
- Liila "Chef Kitten" Series: Chocolate Hug Roll New In Open Bag, Card (No Box)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$22.99or Best Offer+$4.71 delivery
- Items Per Page
