89,000+ results
- Pusheen Pumpkin Hey Chickadee 2017 Plush NWT Halloween Jack-o-Lantern CostumeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$199.99or Best Offer+$8.35 delivery
- Aphmau Meemeows Strawberry Milk Cow 19” Long & 6” Mini Plush Set Of 2 NEW 2025Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$89.99Buy It Now+$16.65 delivery5 watchers
- Minecraft MooBloom Yellow Cow Plush Pillow Large Buttercup Mooshroom Earth 18”Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$60.00Buy It Now+$7.01 delivery
- Pusheen Dome & Swiss roll bundle NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$53.00Buy It Now+$6.53 delivery
- Aphmau Halloween LONG PLUSH 🎃 BLACK CAT 💚 19" GLOWS IN THE DARK! 🔥 SOLD OUT!Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$124.90Buy It Now+$9.90 delivery
- Creep Cat Toy Company 6 ft Spotted Hyena Plush RARE! UN STUFFED RetiredOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$359.00Buy It Now+$17.34 deliverySave up to 5% when you buy more
- Aphmau MeeMeows 5" Strawberry Milk Cow Mini Plush (NEW)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$32.99Buy It Now+$5.85 delivery24 watchers
- Squishmallow 8" Sheba The Purple Cow Bigfoot Hybrid Select Series NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$28.80Buy It Now+$5.47 deliveryFree returnsLast one
Picked For You
Top selling items from trusted sellers | Sponsored- Vintage Boyds Bears Lot Of 5 TF Wuzzies Bears (1 Cat) 4 With Pins, 1 WithoutOpens in a new window or tab$40.00cclevel1016rww (5,428) 99.1%
- Timmy the Tabby Cat: Your 19-Inch Plush Companion-23" with Tail- We Combine ShipOpens in a new window or tab$29.99auswellaplush (1,033) 100%
- Youtooz * Car * 9”Plush * NEW * Sold OutOpens in a new window or tab$49.00yuppieluck (1,658) 98.5%18 watchers
- Auswella® Plush Black Floppy Cat: Your 19-Inch Plush Companion-Stuffed Cat PlushOpens in a new window or tab$29.99auswellaplush (1,033) 100%44 watchers
- TOMY Jim Henson *PAJANIMALS* 4pc LARGE Size PLUSH TOY SET *BRAND NEW WITH TAGS*Opens in a new window or tab$59.99mc2-toys (137,425) 99.7%Last one
- TRIXIE the Plush Soft CAT Stuffed Animal - by Douglas Cuddle Toys - #4625Opens in a new window or tab$21.95douglas_cuddle_toys (9,661) 99.8%Almost gone
- Annabelle's Wish Calf Cow Reindeer 18" Plush Stuffed Christmas Toy Vintage 1997Opens in a new window or tab$79.96ryansmisfittoys (20,241) 99.8%
- Aphmau MeeMeows 5 Inch Strawberry Milk Cow Mini Plush NEW 2025 SOLD OutOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$32.54Was: $34.997% offBuy It Now+$6.55 delivery11 watchers
- Aphmau MeeMeows Plush Sun Cat Yellow Litter 4Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.99or Best Offer+$5.99 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Aphmau MeeMeows 5 Inch Strawberry Milk Cow Mini Plush NEW 2025 READ!!Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$32.99Buy It Now+$6.55 delivery19 watchers
- Walmart Way To Celebrate Easter Cow Plush Stuffed Animal Bunny Ears Green BrownOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$19.99Buy It Now+$6.99 delivery
- Boone The Black Cat | 13 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush | By TigerHart ToysOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$17.99Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns684 sold
- Original Petzzz Calico Cat, Realistic Lifelike Stuffed Interactive Pet ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$41.95Buy It NowFree deliveryLast one
- Shiny Espeon Plush Soft Toy Doll - Teddy Stuffed Animal for FansOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.77Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom PakistanLast one
- Aphmau Meemeows 19 Inch Strawberry Milk Cow Long Plush NEW 2025Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$64.99Buy It Now+$9.45 delivery6 watchers
- Cuddly Highland Cow Soft Toy Teddy Plush Toys Doll Gift 9.5'' 28cmOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$9.99or Best OfferFree deliveryfrom Canada360 sold
- Jazwares Pokémon Soft Plush 8" Sprigatito New with TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.99Buy It NowFree deliveryAlmost gone
- TY NOS 2011 Sanrio Hello Kitty Christmas Holiday Plush Green Bow Santa Hat 15"Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.00or Best Offer+$7.95 delivery in 2-4 days
- Poppy Playtime Smiling Critters 8" Catnap Soft Plush New With TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.99Buy It NowFree deliveryLast one
From our popular brands
Based on number of views and purchases | Sponsored- KellytoyKELLYTOY SQUISHMALLOW 9" RONNIE THE COW - Small Mark SEE PICS. Washed Twice.Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$15.00+$4.44 delivery
- DouglasDouglas Cuddle Toys Cosmo Tortoiseshell Cat 12" Plush Stuffed Animal Tortie HTFOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$89.99+$6.39 delivery
- FiestaGARFIELD RARE Vintage Plush Long Hook & Loop Legs & Arms Plush Fiesta #G70440Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$150.00+$8.00 deliveryExtra 20% off with coupon
- DouglasVTG Douglas The Cuddle Toy Cat Soft Plush Brown Ginger Tiger Kitten StuffedOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$12.99+$6.55 delivery
- IKEAIkea Orange Stripe Cat Rattle Plush 4 Inch Stuffed Animal ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$8.96+$4.95 delivery
- Aphmau MeeMeows Plush Blue Sapphire Cat Litter 4Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.99or Best Offer+$5.99 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Minecraft Mojang 5" Plush Mini Baby Small Mooshroom Red CowOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$3.25or Best Offer+$4.75 delivery
- Squishmallows Cora the Cat Squish-Doos 8 in Plush w Hair Kelly Toys New w TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$13.55Buy It Now+$6.57 delivery
- TY Cloe The Cat Plush The Secret Life Of Pets Stuffed Animal 6" Kitty Purple ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$12.98or Best Offer+$5.25 delivery
- TOMY Jim Henson *PAJANIMALS* 4pc LARGE Size PLUSH TOY SET *BRAND NEW WITH TAGS*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$59.99Buy It NowFree deliveryLast one
- Hello Kitty Sanrio Squishmallows Frankenstein 23 My Melody Watermelon 24 PlushOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$18.00Buy It Now+$8.95 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Squishmallows Benny the Brown Bigfoot in Conner the Cow Costume 8" NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$34.95or Best Offer+$6.00 delivery
- Creep Cat Toy 6FT Spotted Hyena Plush Un-StuffedOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$389.99or Best OfferFree deliveryLast one
- Shapeable Cat Hugger Strange ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$16.95or Best Offer+$4.51 delivery
- Harrods Jelly cat Cherry Cake Limited Edition Cheryl Toy Gift Doll Cute PlushOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$44.90Buy It Now+$9.99 delivery8 watchers
- Vintage Boyds Bears Lot Of 5 TF Wuzzies Bears (1 Cat) 4 With Pins, 1 WithoutOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$40.00or Best OfferFree delivery
- Dorit Duckling Cute Jelly Cat Stuffed Animal Soft Plush Gift Toy NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$39.90or Best OfferFree delivery12 watchers
- OFFICIAL Aphmau MyStreet Emerald Secret Poster (Some Damage)Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$50.00or Best Offer+$8.84 delivery
- Squishville by Squishmallows BRIGHT SQUAD 4Pk Set - 2 MYSTERY MiniOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$9.99Buy It NowFree delivery
- Fatty Zoo Plush Cat Calico Stuffed Animals from Japan Kawaii 16 inches sabatoraOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$69.95Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom JapanLast one
- Fatty Zoo Plush Cat Stuffed Toy Animals from Japan 16 inches American ShorthairOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$69.95Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom JapanLast one
- Poppy Playtime Official GH’S Smiling Critters Catnap CAT NAP Plush Toy 2024 NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$79.61Was: $83.805% offor Best OfferFree deliveryfrom JapanFree returnsAlmost gone
- Gretta 24" DLUX Lying Grey Cat Douglas Cuddle Toy Plush Stuffed Animal Long HairOpens in a new window or tabBrand New2 product ratings - Gretta 24" DLUX Lying Grey Cat Douglas Cuddle Toy Plush Stuffed Animal Long Hair$39.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returnsLast oneTop Rated Plus
- 12Inches Jelly Cat Bashful Beige Bunny Birthday Bunny Stuffed Animal Toy GiftOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$29.89Buy It NowFree delivery6 watchers
- Boo Kitty Build a bear with sleeper AND SOUND BOXOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$99.00Buy It Now+$12.58 delivery15 watchers
- Kitten Tabby Cat 10" Stuffed Animal Plush Toys Toddler Doll Kids GiftsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.99Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom ChinaAlmost gone
- Ginger the Lavish Lanky Cat The Manhattan Toy Company Green Eyes Plush HTF 2015Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.00Buy It Now+$5.99 deliverySave up to 20% when you buy more
- American Girl Doll Isabelle’s Kitten Tutu Plush White Cat Stuffed Animal ToyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$29.97Buy It Now+$3.00 delivery
- Aphmau MeeMeows 6" Mystery Plush Claire's - Monarch Butterfly Cat (sealed)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$65.00Buy It Now+$5.75 deliverySave up to 5% when you buy more
- Aurora Catapillers Orange Cat Plush Stuffed Animal Wings Sharon Lea Larsen 2001Opens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$24.99Buy It Now+$6.99 deliveryFree returns
- Garfield The Movie Baby Garfield 8" PlushOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.00or Best Offer+$4.84 deliveryLast one
- 10" Hello Kitty Sanrio plush corduroy overalls & bow Pink RedOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$12.49or Best Offer+$7.10 delivery
- Stefan The Siamese Cat | 13 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush | By TigerHart ToysOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$20.99Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns1,016 sold
- Squishmallows Kellytoy Plush Hug Mees Cora the Cat 10" NWT New with TagOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$12.99Buy It NowFree delivery
- APHMAU MeeMeows KIM Cat 6" Plush Glitter Edition Series 6Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.99or Best Offer+$5.99 deliveryFree returnsTop Rated Plus
- Black Curly Hair Kitten Cat Plush Toy 14" Stuffed Animal Toddler Doll Gift KidsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$20.45Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom China31 watchers
- Hello Kitty 20" Squishmallows Jumbo Plush and FriendsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$24.99Buy It NowFree delivery30 watchers
- 2025 PEEPS Easter Bunny HIGHLAND COW BUFFALO Tan Plush 12" Dan DeeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.97or Best Offer+$6.40 delivery
- Jellycat IRIS SIAMESE CAT Soft Plush Toy RARE & Hard To Find Ultimate LOVEY !Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$32.99or Best OfferFree deliveryfrom China7 watchers
- NEW Plushie Dreadfuls Victorian Mcgee Cheshire Cat Tote Bag Only. American McGeeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.00Buy It Now+$4.84 delivery
- Douglas Colbie Soft Gray Cat Plush Stuffed Animal' 9"Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$21.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns32 sold
- Poppy Playtime Official GH’S Smiling Critters Catnap CAT NAP Plush Toy 2024 NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$83.50Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom JapanFree returnsLast one
- Squishmallow Kellytoy Plush Sanrio Hello Kitty 8" Easter 2024 NWT NEWOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$17.99Buy It NowFree delivery
- Jelly Cat Bashful Patchwork Brown Bunny Stuffed Animal 7.9 In New in AprilOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$37.05Buy It NowFree deliveryfrom Hong Kong22 watchers
- BABYFIRST LOOI PLUSH CAT EMBROIDERED DETAILING 15” STUFFED ANIMAL CHILD TOYOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$49.25Buy It Now+$9.31 delivery
- Squishmallows Backpack Cam the Calico Cat Mini Bag NWT Tags 10 inch KellytoyOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$2.99or Best Offer+$6.99 deliveryFree returns17 watchersTop Rated Plus
- Gingie 8" Orange Tabby Cat Douglas Cuddle Mini Soft Striped Stuffed Animal PlushOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns10 watchersTop Rated Plus
- Pana The Black Panther | 42 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush | By TigerHart ToysOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$69.99Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns107 sold
- Douglas Mini Bessie Dark Brown and White Cow Plush Stuffed Animal, 6" sittingOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returns9 watchers
- Squishmallows Gigi the Cat Large 15" Orange Plush Pillow Jazwares NwtOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$22.73Was: $25.2510% offBuy It Now+$8.95 delivery
- Poppy Playtime Official GH’S Smiling Critters CAT NAP Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$99.49or Best OfferFree deliveryfrom JapanFree returnsLast one
- Cow Plush Stuffed Animal Toy 9” Blue Eyes Red Ribbon Black And White Moo CowOpens in a new window or tabPre-Owned$8.99or Best OfferFree delivery
- Brand New™ Bartholomew Bear Bumblebee Spring Bee Costume Jelly Cat Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$31.99or Best Offer+$2.50 delivery8 watchers
- 26cm Tyler The Creator Chromakopia Hello Kitty Green Suit Plush Doll Plushie ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$19.99Buy It NowFree delivery19 sold
- Puzzle 19" Calico Cat Douglas Stuffed Animal Plush Cuddle Doll Black Brown WhiteOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$35.95Buy It NowFree deliveryFree returnsLast oneTop Rated Plus
- EARL THE DEAD CAT Plush Toy Reissue NWTOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$24.99Buy It Now+$9.45 delivery151 sold
- Timmy the Tabby Cat: Your 19-Inch Plush Companion-23" with Tail- We Combine ShipOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$29.99Buy It NowFree delivery
- 2025 New Bartholomew Bear Bumblebee Spring Bee Costume Jelly Cat Plush ToyOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$31.79Buy It Now+$0.70 delivery
- Items Per Page
